How many HadithSahih al-Bukhari and Muslim Who Criticized?
QUISTION:
How many hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari and Imam Muslim WhoCriticized ad-Daaruquthni?
ANSWER:
Globally there are about two hundred hadith. Against Saheehal-Bukhari hadith as many as 110, including 32 hadith which is also issued by Imam Muslim. And of Saheeh Muslim as much as 95 hadith including hadith also issued by Imam al-Bukhari. Have a look, mukaddimah book Fat-Hul Bari al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar andal-Imaamain Risaalah Bayna; Muslim Wa ad-Daaruquthni worksShaikh ibn Hadi al-Madkhali and Risaalah Ilzaamaat Waal-at-Tatabbu 'by Shaykh ibn Muqbil Hadi al-Wadi'iy.
QUISTION:
Did Imam ad-Daaruquthni criticize all aspects?
ANSWER:
Criticism does not cover all aspects, some of which he declaresis true and partly false. Sometimes-even often-he only criticizedthe sanad (transmission lines) without matan hadith (text) it.
NB:
Nevertheless, this criticism does not reduce or affect anyagreement on Muslims to accept the hadiths in Sahih al-Bukhariand Muslim and assessments that they are the most right after the al-Quran al-Karim-ed.
(SOURCE: As'ilah Wa Fi Ajwibah its terms Hadiits works ofShaykh al-Mustafa al-'Adawy, hal.37)
No comments:
Post a Comment